Tim Wilson at the NationalPost wrote yesterday an interesting piece on Canada’s Credit Card Wars over regulating interchange and allowing Visa to introduce debit cards in Canada.
Tim states, “While we respect businesses’ desire to manage their expenses, government intervention is not the right solution in a functioning industry.”
I know many Merchants who would be as fast as a wild cat and pounce on this statement. However, after reading more of what Tim had said in his article reminded me how important credit cards are to a business. Tim states:
“Retailers benefit from the speed, efficiency and reliability that only electronic payments can bring. They also receive guaranteed payment and can avoid the need to extend credit directly to their own customers. According to the economics firm Global Insight, over the past two decades, electronic payments have contributed $122-billion to the Canadian economy, which represents nearly 20% of our total GDP growth over the same period.”
In reality, without credit cards businesses would not be able to be as profitable as they are. Just try and imagine how a website would be able to transact without the ability to accept credit cards or even by phone. How would your business sales be without credit cards…?
The REAL ISSUE (if you read between the lines) that merchants are really complaining about is they feel they are paying too much in fees. It always comes down to the “$”.
Now I am all for keeping Merchant processing fees as low as possible. The issue really isn’t Visa and/or Mastercard with their Interchange rates because the interchange rates are not that high. If you have really high rates it’s usually due to your credit card processing company. This is Moneris, Global Payments, Chase-Paymentech, Elavon, First Data, TD Merchant Services, and other sub ISO’s who also broker credit card processing services. They make their money by marking up on top of the interchange rates and they really understand interchange.
Let’s use Tim’s example of:
“Visa Canada’s premium product, the Visa Infinite card, is available to a small subset of cardholders and its interchange rate, which is the small amount of money transferred from one financial institution to another each time a Visa product is used, is one fifth of one percent (0.2%) higher than other card products.”
What merchants don’t understand is how interchange really works and how the Merchant Account companies that sell/set-up merchants are the ones who can sometimes mark-up those rates big time. So if the card present buy rate for a non-reward card is approximately 1.6% for most categories of business and then the infinite card is 0.2% higher that would make the buy rate 1.8%.
Now many Merchant Account Companies will offer those card present cards at almost cost (let’s say 1.7% – only 10 basis points higher than cost) but they’ll mark all infinite cards by a full 1% higher making the Merchant pay 2.8% on those transactions. Now this could be good or bad for your business, it’ll depend on how many of your customers will pay using an infinite card – which you will not know until you are processing.
The question again is do you really understand how your customers transact with you…? If not you will want to figure it out.
This is where it is important that the Merchants understand how interchange works for their type of business category and/or the way their business will transact. By understanding this they will have a better chance at securing competitive rates because they can then look at the interchange tables and understand what the buy rates are from their type of business. However, as long as the Merchant remains uneducated on how all this merchant processing really works they will continue feel confused, alienated and over charged.
Now there have been some major shifts in the industry that have compounded these issues.
“In 2008, Visa introduced the first significant change to its interchange rate structure in 30 years, which resulted in some transactions attracting a higher interchange rate and others attracting a lower rate. Even with the change in structure and the introduction of the Visa Infinite cards, Visa Canada’s effective interchange rate has remained relatively flat at 1.6%. Interchange rates for Visa Canada are transparent and are available on our Web site.”
What people don’t realize is the change in the interchange structure is not really the problem. The REAL challenge is in educating merchants on how all the fees work. They are really just upset because they don’t understand why they are being charge more for some cards and how all their fees have change so much over the last year. The transparency has not been there and so they feel lied to or even like they have been swindle.
And sending a merchant in fine print 60 days before the change that their rates are going to change is NOT being transparent nor is that any kind of education on how it all works.
I don’t blame Merchants – I’d feel the same way if I were in their shoes. Again, as usual with anything in life – it breaks down to poor communication between the card processors and merchants. Which is fine with me – because it’s this type of poor communication that keeps me in business.
I take the time to explain and help merchants understand how all these complex merchant MDR’s work and how to structure an application that is competitive and fair to both the merchants and the card processors.
Regardless, of what I think…what do you think…? Let me know in the comments below.




